National Geographic's Collectors Corner

Collaborative site for collectors, dealers, & anyone interested in our history.

I have been a member since the early seventys and over the years I have accumulated a copy of all issues from 1914 to present ( with the exception of 42 of them from between 1918 and 1922). They are enclosed in N.G.'s slip cases which are enclosed in barrister book cases. I had special ordered the dated cases back to 1940 and I now wish to do the same for the earlier issues. The problem being that the current undated slip cases are too narrow to accomidate the magazines since they were printed on thicker paper. The cases need to be 2 1/2" wide whereas the only ones avialable are 1 1/2".
Can anyone assist me in locating a source of these wider slip cases?

Views: 2431

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Hello Jefferey,

As far as I am aware of, there are no NGS issued slipcases that would accomodate the thicker issues from that time period. What I have done is to acquire duplicate sets of slipcases, which I use for pre-1950. Due to their thickness, sometimes I only can fit 4 or 5 issues in one 6-month case.

There was a company which produced very wide 12-month slipcases for Nat'l Geo Mag, but I do not recall the name of the company. They were black cardboard with either red or yellow spines, with year "19--(blank)" printed in gold-leaf.

I'd post a photo of one as an example if I had one. These are hard to find, and seldom come up on eBay.

- Scott Shier
Thank you very much in sending me a relpy.
I had ordered and received the wider slip cases from NGS but it was toooo many years ago that I do not recall when that was, but they had made them available at one time. My next course of action shall be to inquire with NGS again, maybe if I persist, I shall find someone there that knows of these cases. All of the other times, the individuals had no idea of what I was looking for. I had found out that NGS has changed printers two times since and I have given it some thought to contact them and request of them to make avaliable the wide cases. I had hoped that one of the members of the Corner would be able to assist me, and you have. Thanks again.

I too am a NG magazine collector and have accumulated a complete collection going back to 1928, plus miscellaneous issues prior to 1928.  The undated NG slipcases are much too narrow to comfortably accommodate more than 4, occasionally 5, issues of any magazine year before 1941.  Each pre 1941 year therefore, for the sake of uniformity, requires the purchase of 6 undated slipcases, which represents a considerable expense, around $48 per 6 slipcases, plus shipping adn handling.  Then you can create labels Jan-April, May-August and Sept-Dec for each year.  Office Depot sells Avery labels, 18 labels per sheet.  I use template #8425.  I don't know why NG creates undated slipcases that can only be used for years 1941-1949.  If I accumulate, let's say, a complete collection from 1921-1940, that will cost be 20 x $48 just for the slipcases = $960.00.   It's almost prohibitively expensive.  Pre-1930 magazines in excellent condition, with intact spines, are themselves very costly, perhaps $10-$15 an issue, so we're talking a minimum of $120 per complete pre-1941 year, plus the $50 or so for the cases, = approx $170 per year for the magazines plus slipcases.  It is a very expensive hobby.  I have seen 70-80 year collections on ebay for around $1000, but the demand is almost non-existent at that price.

I have spent at least $5K on my collection over the years, so I will never be able to re-coup my cost.  It's just that, for me, once I collected 50 years or so of the magazines, I find it hard to stop and draw the line somewhere.  I only buy issues in excellent condition, with intact, or near intact spines.  In any case, my entire study is taken up by four 84" bookshelves, so I'm running out of space to house my collection.  My wife wants me to sell the entire collection, but so far I just can't bring myself to do it.

Hello Ron,

I agree or am in sympathy with everything you stated. It boggles the mind to ponder why they sized the non-dated slipcases the way they did. It seems to defeat the purpose of them . . . in that the most likely use for them is precisely the pre-1950 years. Then again, you'd need a few different sizes depending on the era I suppose. If it was someone's intention to slipcase the 1910's, or the first 20 years, it would get interesting in how to break them into year cases or whatnot.

The bulk of the 1920's, all of 1930's and late 40's are the most problematic, and 4, maybe 5 is the most I was able to get into my own duplicate cases. Alas, I acquired a bulk qty. of the dated cases from 1950-1990's on an eBay auction to accomodate my 1920's - 1940's. For now, all my 1908-1919's are individually polybagged and in comic storage boxes because I have not been able to get them gathered into my cases which were separated from me for quite a while.

As you say, it is a quite pricey endeavour, even if buying used slipcases on something like eBay, though not near as much as the NG Store retail price, for sure!

You raise the issue of finding a way to acceptably re-label or label them....there was another thread about that elsewhere in this group back in 2007-2009, not sure when. I think Mel DeVilbiss had found a nice label brand that looked really nice, but I was never able do anything on that front (yet).

For what it's worth, I vote for you to keep your NGM set! I know there's the tendancy that "the wives" don't find Nat Geo collecting amusing or useful, heh heh.

Have you ever come across or posessed any of those old (3rd party) NGM case holders, but the Highsmith Co. ?

Have a good day,

   - Scott S.

Hi Ron,

      Your suggestion is something I had already done, when I found the thicker, earlier issues would not fit 6 to a slipcase. But I put 3 slipcases per year (instead of 2) with 4 months per case (instead of 6). You did state the right month range that you mentioned (Jan-Apr / May-Aug / Sep-Dec) but if you look, that is 3 slipcases, not 6 as you have stated you would need for each year (unless you are putting only 2 issues per slipcase. I think you may have made a mathematical error. So it would only cost you half the amount you stated. You did say "for the sake of uniformity" , which I would take to mean not splitting up years into cases, e.g. end of one year sharing with beginning of the next. As long as only one year is placed in a group of cases, be it 2 cases (6 issues per) or 3 cases (4 issues per) or even 4 cases (3 issues per) then it would be uniformed. Just my opinion.

You could also purchase the 1950's dated slipcases (already the appropriate size for the thicker 1920's issues) and place the labels on them.

Many ways to skin.... whatever the problem is.

I chose the label machine with black background and gold lettering/numbering to continue my collection backwards. When I got to the red brick issues (other than volume 6 which had too many issues) I found the map slip cases worked well (with every issue placed into and archival sleeve before being placed in the NG brown leather slip cases.

Attachments:

A close up example of the labels:

Attachments:

RSS

Members

Legal notice about this site

Note: Any sales or trade arrangements are solely between users of this site; The National Geographic Society is not a party to and does not endorse or promote any particular sales or trade arrangements between collectors, dealers, or others. Due to the immediate nature of this medium, National Geographic Online also does not review, censor, approve, edit or endorse information placed on this forum. Discussion boards on National Geographic Online are intended to be appropriate for family members of all ages. Posting of indecent material is strictly prohibited. The placement of advertisements or solicitations unrelated to National Geographic also is prohibited. National Geographic Online shall review information placed on this forum from time to time and delete inappropriate material that comes to its attention as soon as it is practicable, but cannot guarantee that such material will not be found on the forum. By posting material on this discussion board you agree to adhere to this policy prohibiting indecent, offensive or extraneous advertising material, and to legally assume full and sole responsibility for your posting.

© 2023   Created by Cathy Hunter.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service